First off, I want to make it explicitly clear that I enjoyed VividCon and am very happy that I attended this year. I met some amazing people there and the experience got me thinking and finally posting it this journal!
That being said, I did leave the con one day early. I left because (1) I did not have a vid at any of the shows and was sorta bitter about this; (2) I didn't relate to a lot of the fandoms for the
vids shown at the con; (3) I wasn't having as much fun as I have had at HP cons; and (4) I didn't feel like I could fully speak my mind.
Disregarding #1 (which is sort of a dumb reason to leave but I am being honest), I liken my VVC experience to the stereotype of an American visiting Paris for the first time. I am from the America of fandoms. Harry Potter is freaking huge! Like America, it so damn big that it has factions and subdivisions (LOL at the idea of the State of Snarry or the Republic of Wizard Rock). Like America, HP is very centered around a mainstream concept that everybody knows. Just like a lot of people in America don't have passports, a lot of HP fans are ONLY HP fans and don't travel the world of other fandoms or go to other cons. Like America, HP is relatively young. For the record, by young, I mean "not around in the early 1990's" as opposed to "full of young people."
VVC and the part of the vidding fandom who attend VVC are the fandom convention equivalent of Paris. I guess in my analogy the vidding fandom in general is France because not everyone who lives in France also lives in Paris...and not everyone who vids goes to VVC. Like France, vidding is relatively old and has serious history. Just like the average Parisian typically speaks French and is knowledgeable about French history, the average VVC attendee usually knows some amount of vidding history and has some level of vidding skill. Like the average Parisian, the average VVC attendee probably has a fandom passport and plays in a bunch of different fandoms.
Some Americans are really put off by visiting Paris. There are complaints about the people being rude, the streets being confusing, and the food being "strange." Some people go once and swear they will never go back. As I said before, I am talking stereotypes here. Personally I love Paris and have never had a bad experience there. I think this is largely a matter of luck.
At VVC, I felt like an unlucky American in Paris. I didn't know all the history and didn't relate to the fandoms. I didn't know many people and no one knew me...but most people knew each other. Some conversations I tried to participate in about fandoms or people I did not know sounded like French to me. I also felt really "patriotic" about Harry Potter fandom and this seemed to be looked down upon by some people.
My expectations for VVC were largely based on my HP convention experiences. One big shock for me was being labeled a "feral vidder." There is no label like this in the HP world. This term was applied to me a few times and at first I didn't mind at all. I thought it was really funny actually. However, the more I thought about it, the more it started to bug me because it implies that I am somehow unrefined and sloppy because I have not been part of the VVC community. It disregards the importance of the fact that I have been part of the HP vidding community. Just because I met most of my vidding friends on YouTube and
accio_vids instead of at VVC does not mean my community is any less of a community. I liken this to the sort of Parisian snobbery a lot of Americans complain about. Not everyone in Paris is like that, but if you meet someone who is or that attitude is inadvertently conveyed to you, it is not a pleasant experience.*
My experience was also like visiting Paris because it rocked. I saw great vids and met great people. After all, Paris does have the Eiffel Tower, the Louvre, delicious food, and the best shopping in the world. There's a reason people fly across the world to go to there.
I am not planning to be like those Americans who write off Paris as a bad place and never visit again. I plan to keep in touch with people I met at VVC and try to be active in the VVC community. I might even go again. Maybe next time if I think more about context (and perhaps study some French) I will have a better trip.
*Note:
tjwritter helped me embrace the term "feral" recently. When I told her about its meaning in the VVC community, she responded with something like, "Well, I think as a vidder, I would see being wild and untame as a compliment!" I decided that she was right.